Cyclops took to the stage next, performing Creed‘s “My Sacrifice.” Representing Team Bad, he referred to himself as a “villain” and the judges had a difficult time pinning him down. Jenny guessed Cobra Kai star William Zabka, while Nicole guessed actor Danny McBride.
The dramatic evening continued with Firefly, representing Team Good, who had to stop in the middle of her performance after she began choking in her headpiece. Medics rushed on stage to assist and escorted her backstage. Ever the professional, she returned later in the show and nailed a version of Chaka Khan‘s “Ain’t Nobody.” The judges were in awe of her vocal abilities. Ken zeroed in on Alicia Keys, meanwhile Jenny guessed it was either singer Monica or comedian Aisha Tyler.
Finally, Ram sang Cheap Trick‘s “I Want You To Want Me” on behalf of Team Bad. All three judges agreed that he was somebody from the football world. Jenny argued that he reminded her of University of Michigan head coach Jim Harbaugh. Robin hypothesized he could be NFL Hall of Famer Peyton Manning, while Ken guessed recent Super Bowl champion Matthew Stafford.
When the dust settled, it was McTerrier who got sent to the dog house.
When his headpiece came off—for the second time!—the pup was revealed to be pastry chef and Food Network star Duff Goldman, who rolled around on the ground like a dog while accepting his fate.
Keep scrolling to find out more clues about the first batch of mystery contestants this season! The Masked Singer airs Wednesdays at 8 pm on Fox.
